Categories: News

Why A Kenyan High Court Rejected An AI-generated Court Filing

A judge of the High Court of Kenya has struck out a Notice of Motion application after determining that the submitted documents were generated by a computer and failed to meet basic procedural requirements.

In a ruling delivered virtually, Justice Bahati Mwamuye said the application filed by Nayan Mansukhlal Savla against the Commission on Administrative Justice and the Kenya Psychiatric Association did not comply with the Civil Procedure Rules at the Milimani Law Courts, according to local media Capital FM Kenya.

The court found that the Notice of Motion did not meet Order 51 Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Rules of Kenya (2010), which requires a specific notice statement to appear at the foot of every motion application. The supporting affidavit was also found to be defective for not complying with Order 19, Rules 4 and 5.

Justice Mwamuye said both the motion and the affidavit appeared to be machine-generated, raising broader concerns about the use of artificial intelligence in legal filings.

“Computer-generated documents or outputs of ‘artificial intelligence’ cannot be a proper substitute for human-drawn documents,” the judge said. “A party must draw and file their documents on their own accord and by their own hand or through their legal representatives.”

While the judge noted that the defects were largely technical, he ruled they were serious enough to warrant striking out the application. However, the petitioner was allowed to file a fresh application and affidavit that meet the required legal standards

Advertisements
Montage Africa

Recent Posts

LORENZO BRENTE: FSB MANAGEMENT AND GEORGES NGAY-KATALAY PREPARE HIS INTERNATIONAL RISE — CHAMPIONSHIP FIGHT ANNOUNCED IN LONDON FOR MARCH 2027

FSB MANAGEMENT, UNDER THE LEADERSHIP OF GEORGES NGAY-KATALAY, TAKES ON EXCLUSIVE WORLDWIDE SPORTS MANAGEMENT OF…

1 day ago

Secret votes and vetoes: How will the next UN chief be picked?

By Edna Mohamed Secret votes, coloured ballot papers, straw polls and backroom efforts to force…

1 day ago

ECOWAS Competition Authority Inaugurates Network of Economic Journalists

The ECOWAS Regional Competition Authority (ERCA) has inaugurated the Network of Economic Journalists to promote…

1 day ago

US basketball player arrested with 34kg of cannabis at Nigerian airport

A professional American basketball player has been arrested in Nigeria with 33.95kg (75lbs) of cannabis…

1 day ago

Sudan, Ethiopia trade accusations over armed groups

By AP Tensions between Sudan and Ethiopia have escalated, with each accusing the other of…

1 day ago

South Sudan postpones first general election from December to February

By Rédaction Africanews with AFP People in South Sudan began registering to vote on Saturday…

1 day ago